Systematic review of the addition of vincristine plus steroid pulses in maintenance treatment for childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia - an individual patient data meta-analysis involving 5659 children
Abstrakt
Vincristine plus steroid pulses have long been a part of maintenance treatment in many protocols for childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL). A collaborative individual patient data meta-analysis of all randomised trials of the addition of vincristine plus prednisone/prednisolone (VP) pulses in childhood ALL was updated and extended to include trials comparing vincristine plus dexamethasone (VD) pulses to maintenance without pulses.
VP pulses improved event-free survival (EFS) (70 center dot 1% vs. 62 center dot 0% at 5 years; odds ratio (OR) = 0 center dot 71; 95% confidence interval (CI) = 0 center dot 61-0 center dot 84; P = 0 center dot 00004); VD pulses did not have a significant effect (80 center dot 9% vs. 79 center dot 9% 5 year EFS; OR = 0 center dot 94; 95% CI = 0 center dot 80-1 center dot 11; P = 0 center dot 5). Heterogeneity between groups (VP or VD) was significant (P = 0 center dot 02).
Neither treatment clearly affected overall survival. The difference between the VP and VD results is probably due to the greater early intensity of the backbone of the VD trial protocols and improved outcome seen in the VD trials, which were more recent.
Pulses may still be useful in cases where less intensive early therapy is used and the balance between these treatments in terms of both effectiveness and toxicity needs to be considered.