Charles Explorer logo
🇬🇧

Doctors and law

Publication at Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Faculty of Law |
2014

Abstract

Authors offer some insights into the role of legislation in democratic society and they consider some possibilities of physicians to affect provisions of health laws. As an example of possible amendments initiated by physicians they cite two provisions of the Law No. 372/2011 Sb., On health services and on conditions of their provision. § 41 "Duties of the patient and other persons" could inspire hopes, which it could not fulfil.

Democratic society does not dispose of measures, which could force the patient to keep therapeutic regime. Authors believe that explicit declaration of the responsibility transfer in the case of non compliance of the patient would be more appropriate.

In § 36 "Advance directives" there is the conflict between strict requirements on elaboration of the advance directives document and the ease of physician's refusal to follow patient's directives. § 36 introduce the term "active inflicting of death". Definition of the term is in conflict with prevailing consensus in bioethics literature and with prevailing consensus in expert's opinion in West Europe.

Provisions of the law do not leave the space for termination of aggressive treatment at the end of life and they force physicians to provide treatment inconsistent with the wish of the patient.