Charles Explorer logo
🇬🇧

Mass of Bodies, Body as a Mass: The Other of the Other in Jean-Luc Nancy

Publication at Faculty of Humanities |
2020

Abstract

This paper aims to explore and expand Jean-Luc Nancy's notion of the body as a mass as he drafted it in his "On the Soul" lecture. He conceptualizes the soul as the (how- ever minimal) reflection of the fact that we have (or we are) a body, thus the concep- tion of the body as a mass may offer possibilities to think the body outside or prior to this reflection.

In the article, I expand on three types of bodies. The first of these possibilities is an abstracted body Nancy ascribed to St.

Augustine, a body which has been criticized by feminist scholars like Judith Butler. The second one is a hypothetical pre-body proposed by the object-oriented philosopher Graham Harman that may have existed before the actual body emerges.

The last one is the disintegrated rotting body in two different contexts: European baroque imagery and asubha kammaṭṭhāna, a Thai meditational practice. All three types of bodies-as-a-mass are legitimate conceptualizations of what Nancy indicates.

However, the mass quality is the very nonconceptuality, which is therefore the ultimate outcome that I had to reach.