Water Exchange (WE) and Quality Improvement-Enhanced Advanced Adenoma Detection A Pooled Data Analysis of 6 Randomized Controlled Trials
Abstrakt
Introduction: Advanced adenomas (>= 10 mm in diameter, >25% villous, or high-grade dysplasia), a marker of colorectal cancer risk, are used to stratify patients for closer surveillance. Modern accessories, endoscopes, and age-adjusted evaluation have variable impacts on the advanced adenoma detection rate (AADR).
In 1 randomized controlled trial (RCT) comparing air insufflation (AI) with water exchange (WE), the right colon AADR was significantly increased by WE. Four network meta-analyses reported that WE significantly increased overall adenoma detection rate (ADR), but the impact on AADR was not addressed.
Aim: The aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that WE significantly increased AADR compared with AI. Method: Six Clinicaltrial.gov-registered RCTs were reported by a group of WE investigators.
Data including AADR (primary outcome) and overall ADR (secondary outcome) were pooled. Results: A total of 5407 patients were randomized to AI (2699) and WE (2708).
Compared with AI, WE significantly increased AADR (5.7% vs. 8.3%, P=0.001) and overall ADR (20.9% vs. 27.4%, P=0.001). Conclusions: In contrast to published reports, which showed variable impacts on AADR, WE was consistent in increasing AADR in 6 reported RCTs.
The pooled data confirm that the impact of WE in increasing AADR was significant. The significantly enhanced overall ADR indicated that WE provided a higher quality outcome than AI.
The significant improvement in AADR confirmed WE to be clinically relevant and has finally arrived as a timely addition to colorectal cancer prevention programs.