In the paper by FE James, VS Johnson, ZM Lenard and CS Mansfield published in the New Zealand Veterinary Journal 56, 85-88, 2008, entitled, "Severe haemoptysis associated with seizures in a dog", the authors reported a case of repeated haemoptysis and radiographically visible severe bilateral alveolar lung pattern in a 7-year-old German Shepherd dog suffering from generalised tonic-clonic seizures. On the basis of several other examination methods, they concluded that "The cause of the haemoptysis could not be defined in this dog, but was considered likely to be due to either severe neurogenic pulmonary oedema or rupture of the pulmonary capillaries secondary to seizures." Further in the text they stated that "Haemoptysis associated with severe neurogenic pulmonary oedema, rather than traumatic rupture of the pulmon ary capillaries may have occurred in this dog." I agree with these statements.